top of page
Pasta and Wine





Mattituck Michelangelo's

The ORIGINAL Michelangelo’s!  
(Yes, THE Original)
Authentic Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria located on the North Fork, Long Island!
Past our exquisite pizzeria store-font you will discover a hidden gem; our beautiful, lavish, newly-renovated dining room. Our elegant atmosphere prompts the utmost relaxation and romance, while seamlessly satisfying all your dining dreams. 

About Us

We are known for an extensive variety of specialty pizzas, and an expansive dining menu—featuring a vast array of classic Italian dishes. We take immense pride in our diversified weekly specials, grandiose portions, and consistent quality flavors.
Complete any cuisine with a delectable libation from our alluring bar, wine presented by the glass or bottle, and a delicious dessert served by the sweetest staff. (Yes, it IS true what you hear about the Tiramisu!)
Whether you are schmoozing on a first date, entertaining your entire extended family (we promise to help you impress the in-laws), or throwing a private party or extraordinary event, Mattituck Michelangelo’s will provide the finest experience for your entire guest list to enjoy.
We can’t wait to dazzle you with a delightful dining experience and serve you our famous Italian flavors.
Mangiamo! (Lets eat!) 
bottom of page